It is absolutely not true that the government is refusing to publish information on hunting, requesting by BirdLife Malta, said the Parliamentary Secretariat responsible for animal rights.
Figures will be published in the next Ornis Committee meeting, it added, while noting this is still being compiled as this is collected by different entities including the police and Mepa, before it is passed to the Ornis Committee.
The government's statement was issued after BirdLife Malta (BLM) yesterday sent an urgent communication to the European Commission concerning the government’s failure to make available vital information concerning the 2013 spring hunting season.
The government siad: “It would be deceitful to say the government is refusing to publish figures as this implies the government would be hiding information”.
BirdLife Malta also knows that its members regularly attended meetings of the Derogation Monitoring Board, set up for the first time by the government to show it is serious and responsible on the matter, and the Ornis committee, which publishes the figures.
The government expects BirdLife Malta to show responsibility and maturity in its statements.
In a statement to the media issued this morning, Nicholas Barbara, BirdLife Malta Conservation Manager said, “Every year we report to the European Commission our analysis of the spring hunting derogation in relation to the correct application of the Birds Directive. Such reports rely on data being made available from government authorities regarding numbers of registered hunters, number of birds reported shot, and enforcement efforts expended.”
This information was promised to BirdLife Malta through the Ornis Committee upon which it sits by June 2013. Formal requests for information were alternatively sent to relevant government officers, with information having been subsequently received from the Government Veterinary Division and the Armed Forces of Malta, but not from the Malta Environment and Planning Authority, the Derogation Monitoring Board within the Parliamentary Secretariat in charge of hunting matters, nor from the Malta Police Force. Such information remains undisclosed despite the government having already compiled and submitted such information in the format of a report to the Commission in June.
Mr Barbara said, “We have never had a problem with obtaining such data before, but this year the government is refusing to publish figures, giving the excuse that they are still the subject of ‘discussions’ between the European Commission and Malta. But the data themselves are not under discussion - facts and figures such as reported catches of Turtle Dove and Quail and police convictions cannot be altered subject to the Commission’s comments on the government’s report.”
Mr Barbara went on to say that: “Environmental information such as that pertaining to a spring hunting derogation should be in the public domain, and not riddled with bureaucratic procedures aimed at keeping this information from being shared publicly,” adding that the lack of provision of such information goes against the spirit of the Freedom of Information Act and the Aarhus Convention to which Malta is a signatory.
In the latest response from the government, requests for data are now being referred to a new ‘Acting Head of the Wild Birds Regulation Unit’, a unit set up within the Parliamentary Secretariat for Agriculture, Fisheries and Animal Welfare, which has responsibility for compiling hunting derogation reports for the European Commission.
Steve Micklewright, Executive Director of BirdLife Malta said, “We hope that the delay in data provision is not a sign that simple requests such these for information that should be freely available in the public domain will be subject to Ministerial interference and blocking tactics.”
